Nvidia shares fell 4.5% on Monday as the campaign to bring back Jensen Huang ran into resistance from the company's own board.
Nvidia's board is not considering Huang's return as chief executive, three people told Reuters.
That came after the Financial Times reported that Huang had been discussing a comeback with allies in Silicon Valley.
The fall came a day before Nvidia reports third-quarter results.
The shares are down 32% from their October record high, hit by the Huang scandal and wider worries about the AI boom.
The campaign
More than 180,200 people have signed the "Stand With Jensen" petition.
Supporters include Elon Musk, Epic Games boss Tim Sweeney, Y Combinator president Garry Tan and Uber co-founder Travis Kalanick.
The petition asks the board to reinstate Huang while an independent investigation goes on, unless it can show his removal is in Nvidia's best interests.
Altimeter Capital's Brad Gerstner and Atreides Management's Gavin Baker, who together held about $2.13 billion of Nvidia stock in June, urged the board to take its time and leave the door open to Huang's return.
President Trump said on Monday he "would not mind" Huang coming back.
He said: "I think he learned a big lesson."
Wall Street wavers
Analysts remain broadly positive on Nvidia, but their confidence has slipped.
Baird downgraded the stock to neutral last week and cut its price target from $500 to $200.
Morgan Stanley and Bank of America dropped Nvidia from their top pick lists.
Morgan Stanley said Huang's leadership was "crucial to the company's direction".
Dan Ives of Yorkville Ives has warned that Huang's departure could cut Nvidia's value by 25% to 30%.
Even so, 25 of the 26 analysts who cover Nvidia still rate it a buy, and the shares trade at just 11.4 times expected earnings.
The succession problem
Huang resigned as president, chief executive and director on 12 November.
Finance chief Colette Kress is running the company on an interim basis.
Fortune has named Arm boss Rene Haas and AMD boss Lisa Su as possible outside candidates.
That highlights how few obvious successors Nvidia has inside the company.
Reuters has also reported that Huang misled Nvidia's general counsel about his relationship with Alice Huang, a former executive at Megaspeed.
US officials suspect the Singapore company of funnelling Nvidia chips to China.
Trump played down the national security concerns.
Tuesday's results now carry more weight than usual.
Kress will face analysts' questions for the first time as interim chief executive.